What's new
British Ordnance Collectors Network

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Need help with an old Chinese (!) 1" Nordenfelt case headstamp

ogreve

Well-Known Member
Hi All (possibly Diaofushui in particular),

As many of you probably know, I fully specialise in Japanese and Chinese ordnance, up to the end of WW2.

Earlier today, my Belgian friend and middleman received the round for me that is shown in the attached pictures. It is a Chinese early 1" Nordenfelt round, and as old Chinese ammunition is one of the very few realms that's even tougher to acquire and study (due to little available documentation and specimens), I'm hoping someone can answer a few questions for me. Please pardon my ignorance regarding the various aspects of Chinese ammunition, date periods and information about their armed forces. It is an area that I have yet to start researching properly.

The headstamp style is what I perceive as "typically old Chinese", yet, this very style of headstamp so far has ONLY been seen by me twice, with the other occurrence being on a 37x94R case. My round came from Japan, and AFAIK the 37x94R casing (which is not owned by me) too.

The questions:
1) A translation request: AFAIK the three Kanji between the * and the anchor, read 'arsenal', but do they also mention a city or arsenal name?
2) The other two Kanji are numerals, being '2' and '4'; most likely read as '24', but possibly as '42'. I'm quite sure that this is an indication for the year of manufacture, but even though I know the Japanese date systems very well, I'm not yet trained in the Chinese ones. Can someone tell me what year this is? One possibility is 1935, but I'm not sure...
3) The anchor is a mystery to me: it shows the very style that one so often encounters on early IJN used ammo. It's not a Japanese arsenal anchor, but my theory is that this style anchor is likely to be used for Japanese contract ammo. Does anyone know if China also used this exact same anchor, and if China even had much of a Navy and used this calibre around the period of +/- 1900 - 1940)? Do note that the anchor is the ONLY marking that has been 'double stamped'! It is well possible that all markings were applied in/by China, and only the anchor in/by Japan.
Chances are that at some point in time the Chinese fulfilled some Japanese contracts for 1" Nordenfelt and 37x94R ammo, and used this style headstamp. If so, it would not seem likely to me that the date on it could really be 1935, as at that time it is very hard to believe the Chinese would voluntarily be manufacturing ammo for Japan. Can anyone tell me anything about this particular anchor style in relation to Chinese ammo?
I *really* wonder if the anchor is Chinese (too) or Japanese only. If the latter is the case, apart from contract ammo it could possibly also be captured ammo. I hope someone knows anything about this.
4) Does anyone else have items with this particular style headstamp?

Finally, the brass sleeve of the projectile is still located in the casing (which has been fired, BTW). When I receive the round (which should happen on September 20th) I shall try to pry it out and check if it has markings on it.

Thanks in advance and cheers,
Olafo


51fee0bd2405f.JPG51fee0b6a3a5a.JPG51fee0ae28944.JPG
 
Last edited:
You need to get Ken Elk's book on Chinese ammo. He does not illustrate this headstamp but shows several others.

I have sent him the picture of your round for comment and will post his answer.

Regards
TonyE
 
Hi Tony,

Ooooh, I didn't realise Ken had a book (finished) about that!!
Of course I do have his books on Japanese ammo, and shall be happy to buy the Chinese one too from him.
Do you know if he will be at the ECRA fair on September 20th, or someone else who could bring a copy along for me?

Thanks and cheers,
Olafo
 
Excellent! I shall most gladly have a chat with the both of you then! :)
And... if Ken brings copies of his book on Chinese ammo, can you please ask him to reserve one for me? That's a book I most definitely do NOT want to miss!

Cheers,
Olafo
 
Most probably, it is Japanese, not Chinese, Usually Chinese Arsenals are named 兵工厂,while japanese arsenals are called 造兵厂。
 
Hi Diaofushui and EOD,

Firstly, thanks a lot to both of you for your answer; both of them help me further yet also confuse me somewhat. :p

To start with Diaofushui's reply: it's very interesting to read that difference between the both languages. I checked one of my headstamps, which seems to indeed have the 兵工 Kanji ideograms on it (read from right to left), with in front of it two further Kanji ideograms (which I think depict 'Shanghai') and after the 'arsenal Kanji ideograms', there's a single Kanji ideogram that appears to be the very same one as is present directly to the right of the anchor on the 1" Nordenfelt casing. I wonder what that Kanji ideogram means...
IF the case is indeed Japanese (or Japanese restamped) then that would explain the similarity in the anchors. The '24' could then surely only mean 'Meiji 24' (i.e. 1891). The difficulty with thinking of it as Japanese is that the headstamp style is completely distinct from that what I have seen so far on Japanese ammo. Having written that, so far the Navy specimens seen by me do not go as far back as 1891. The oldest ones I have were produced between 1898-1901 by EOC. The oldest 'true Japanese arsenal manufactured' casing that I have incoming is from 1903, made by the Kure arsenal. I'm not sure what was used prior to 1898, but should the 1" Nordenfelt casing indeed be Japanese, then that could be a tremendous find for that research! I have asked the owner of the similarly marked 37x94R casing for the two numerals (not seen in the pictures I have of it). I wonder what they are.
Still the 'round' headstamp style comes across to me as 'typically Chinese', but I'll make sure to keep the option of it being fully Japanese open too!

EOD: Thanks for that reference! I wasn't aware of that and it is very helpful, especially for the arsenal markings! I browsed over it and I seem to have found some inconsistencies with what I see on artillery casings; like e.g. the one with the 'double diamond' arsenal mark (according to the reference: Kunghsien arsenal (Gong Xian)) is written to only appear on post-WW2 ammo. Yet I have a 75x212R casing with that marking, and a year indication of '25', i.e. 1936. I also have a 75x118R casing that was interpreted by native Chinese speakers as 'Shanghai factory made' which has different Kanji ideograms than mentioned for Shanghai, and the same goes for Kwantung pre-Japanese occupation (?) manufacture. Anyway, it's a great reference for making a start! I'll study it more thoroughly later!

The above shows what I meant with 'confusing'; whenever I think to have put something in the proper context, other information is presented that suggests otherwise. :S
But... in a way that's also what's so much fun about collecting old Japanese and Chinese ammo: lots of stuff still to research properly! :p

Cheers,
Olafo
 
Hi Sen,

Can you please check the translation on this Chinese headstamp of mine?
The complete headstamp is shown, and I also have chopped up three logical parts. Everything reads from right to left, and is highly similar to one that I transcribed (using translations coming from two distinct native Chinese speakers at different restautants over here) in this thread (in particular in post #21): http://www.bocn.co.uk/vbforum/threads/71112-Japanese-75mm-Shell-Case-Carboot-Find!/page3

My case appears to be quite comparable to it, but the date differs and I don't know which year it is exactly (surely close to 1910 too). Can you please check the date, the arsenal and the interpretation of the 'calibre designation'?
Note: the date part seems to consist of 5 Kanji ideograms, of which the leftmost is very hard to make out; it's also poorly visible in the picture, but if I have something to compare it too, I could look it up.
Loosely translated, I think it reads (as per the order of the 3 close-up images):
"Shanghai factory (arsenal) made"
"75 milimeter casing/bullet/round"
"Date"

Cheers,
Olafo

75x118R_Chinese_headstamp_complete_small.jpg75x118R_Chinese_headstamp_arsenal_small.jpeg75x118R_Chinese_headstamp_calibre_small.jpeg75x118R_Chinese_headstamp_date_small.jpeg
 
Hi, Olafo;

This case is Chinese case.
上海兵工廠, meaning Shanghai Arsenal .
民國八年, meaning the eighth year of Republic of China , referring to the year 1919.
七生五彈壳, meaning 7.5cm Case . 七--7, 生--cm, 五--5, meaning 7cm and 5, that is 75mm.

So totally, this is a 75mm case made by Chinese Shanghai Arsenal in 1919.

Hope it helps.

Regards

sen
 
Hi Sen,

Thanks a million for your translations!
These are very helpful. The arsenal and calibre parts are pretty much what I already gathered from the translations obtained from the other Chinese speakers, but they weren't completely sure on the proper contextual meaning, and it is good to see them fully properly interpreted (by you) now.
Also: the date was not yet known to me. That too was very helpful.
And... I now also think to know the answer to a question about a different style Chinese headstamp that I didn't ask about here. I have a 37x112R casing which has been attributed to the Kwantung arsenal (alledgedly Mukden, from before the Japanese occupation). This has a headstamp that reads: "民 15.1". I always wondered what the single Kanji ideogram meant, and now I assume it refers to 'Republic', indicating the date era, and hence putting the year of manufacture in 1926. Can you please tell me if that interpretation is indeed correct, or not?
Thanks!
Olaf
 
Hi, Olaf;

Yes, you are right. If you have any questions, feel free to let me know.



Sen

Hi Sen,

Thanks a million for your translations!
These are very helpful. The arsenal and calibre parts are pretty much what I already gathered from the translations obtained from the other Chinese speakers, but they weren't completely sure on the proper contextual meaning, and it is good to see them fully properly interpreted (by you) now.
Also: the date was not yet known to me. That too was very helpful.
And... I now also think to know the answer to a question about a different style Chinese headstamp that I didn't ask about here. I have a 37x112R casing which has been attributed to the Kwantung arsenal (alledgedly Mukden, from before the Japanese occupation). This has a headstamp that reads: "民 15.1". I always wondered what the single Kanji ideogram meant, and now I assume it refers to 'Republic', indicating the date era, and hence putting the year of manufacture in 1926. Can you please tell me if that interpretation is indeed correct, or not?
Thanks!
Olaf
 
Top