What's new
British Ordnance Collectors Network

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Punic War expert needed

sksvlad

Well-Known Member
I heard a claim that the word PUNITIVE comes from the word PUNIC. The idea being that Carthage was annihilated by Rome as a punishment. Is this true?
 
Punitive is derived from the Latin verb punire - to punish, whereas Punic refers to the Phoenicians.
 
I know this one!

Something remains from my teenage Latin studies (one of my teachers called me a specialist in neologims and barbarisms - I was never in trouble to invent a new Latin word on a French or Spanish basis if I was stuck in a translation to Latin, or to build Latin sentences using what is called in French "latin de cuisine" ).

All this was a long time ago, but some of the "funny stories" stuck as words like these ones were the kind that had on me the same effect as honey for a bee :

Punic derives from the Latin "poenus" and "punicus", terms deriving from the ancient Greek word "phoinis" and its plural "phoinikes" designing the people we now under the vocable of Phenicians - and this includes the Carthaginians who were originaly Phonician settlers in North Africa.

Punitive comes from the latin "poena" itself deriving form the greek "poine" = punition, penalty.

Well, it's obvious that for an average French Lycee pupil in front of a latin "theme" or "version", "poena" was of course the feminine of "poenus", isn't it? :po_O
 
Last edited:
What i remember from the school : Translation of Tite Live , the sentence of Caton "Delenda est Carthago" and the three Punic Wars .
The origin of Punic is Poenus (Phoenician).
For the romans , the Carthaginians were these Phoenician people.
For me, punitive is quite different , comes from the latin punire (poena) .
 

Attachments

  • punic1.jpe
    punic1.jpe
    81.3 KB · Views: 4
  • punic2.jpe
    punic2.jpe
    139.6 KB · Views: 4
  • punic3.jpg
    punic3.jpg
    89.3 KB · Views: 4
Top