What's new
British Ordnance Collectors Network

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

120mm French or German WWI ?

Tarbelin51

Tarbelin51

Well-Known Member
Ordnance approved
Hello

we found this shell 120mm in french profile Mle 1878.
But with what looks like a German fuze against the cold markings that are on the brass section.
Someone would have an idea ?
Size:
High without fuze: 350mm
Ring Band to base: 24mm
diameter: 120mm

-IMG_0028_2.jpg-IMG_0029_2.jpg-IMG_0026_2.jpg-IMG_0032_2.jpg-IMG_0033_2.jpg-IMG_0034_2.jpg
 
Hi Tarbelin,
I saw this mark (diamond in a circle) somewhere, but WHERE ?????
If there is only this mark and those 6 branch star, should it not can be a simple plug ?
I looked in our WW I french, german and belgian docs and nowhere found a trace of these fuze. Let us search on another way !



Yoda
 
Just checked my sources and agree with trrr, its Rheinische Metallwaren und Maschinen Fabrik, and if it is a fuze I cant find any reference to it..
 
But why fire it with the transport-plug still in it? Is there a secondary igniter in the projectile?
Could this projectile be a part of the "Beutewaffen"? You know, stocks of ammo and weapons,
captured of the French and re-used by the germans.

Just my 2cents
 
A little bump to this topic;

Yesterday I've heard 3 plausible reasons why this projectile is how it is;

1) PRACTICE: it is possible that this is a practice round, instead of explosives it could be filled with sand.

2&3) It could be a fire-at-night situation where you've got 2 possibilities;
-----A: the soldiers were drunk (all 5 of them???)

-----B: and that's a bit more acceptable; They did this on purpose
you know how they say to not wake a sleeping dog, well, those Germans must have thought the same.
They got their fire-mission but it was a quit night. So to not draw fire from the enemy, they fired the
rounds with the transport-plug. There for the shell landed without exploding.
The officer who gave the order could hear them firing so for him it was a done deal.

So, what do you guys think. Maybe one of you already heard of one of those reasons possible on either
side of the battlefield. :p

edit: the copper-belt is about 1,5cm wide right? So I thought this means the projectile is completely German.
 
Hello Guys

Thank you all for your reasoning.
Unfortunately our projectille left in destruction and had no time to do an X -Ray.
It remains a mystery .
But I still think a reuse of a french shells by the Germans, with perhaps a fuze without detonator ( Obus black powder) or for the star to enhanced primer.

Following the next discovery ...

Tarbelin51
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top